Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-15 Keychron | Custom Mechanical Keyboards for Mac, Windows ... 0 views

MDA vs OEM PBT Keycaps: New York Set and Bluish Black White

MDA vs OEM PBT Keycaps: New York Set and Bluish Black White

Compare the MDA New York full set with the OEM Bluish Black White set: profile feel, keyboard compatibility, layout coverage, and price, using only confirmed catalog facts.

Start with your keyboard, not the profile name

Choosing between MDA and OEM PBT keycaps usually starts with typing feel, but the first filter is compatibility. These two sets are not interchangeable across every Keychron board, and the catalog lists which models each one covers.

The MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set - New York is a 140-key full set aimed at ANSI-layout boards. The OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White comes in multiple versions, and the version you pick determines which keyboards it fits. Neither set includes a keyboard.

What the catalog confirms about the New York set

  • MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set Keycap Set - New York: Full Set (140 keys) in the New York colorway, MDA profile, dye-sub PBT. A 140-key count suggests broad layout coverage, but the catalog still limits it to specific ANSI-layout models rather than every keyboard.
    MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set Keycap Set - New York
    MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set Keycap Set - New York
  • MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set Keycap Set - New York: Fits ANSI layout Q series (excluding Q8, Q9 Plus, Q10, Q11, Q60), Q Pro series (excluding Q8 Pro, Q10 Pro, Q11 Pro, Q14 Pro), V series (excluding V8, V10), 81 Pro, Lemokey L1, L3, L4, P1, P1 Pro, P1 HE, K2, K2 Pro, K2 Max, K2 HE, K4, K4 Pro, K6, K6 Pro, K8, K8 Pro, K8 Max, K10, K10 Pro, K10 Max, K12, K12 Pro, K14, K14 Pro, C1, C1 Pro, C2, and C2 Pro. This is the definitive compatibility list for the New York set. If your board is not named, the catalog does not confirm fit.
  • MDA Dye-Sub PBT Full Set Keycap Set - New York: No discount codes can be used for this keycap set. Budget comparisons should use the listed price without assuming a promo code will apply.

What the catalog confirms about the Bluish Black White set

  • OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White: OEM profile, dye-sub PBT, available in Version A, Version B, and Version C (Full Set). The OEM set splits compatibility by version, so the same colorway can fit different keyboard families depending on the version you order.
    OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White
    OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White
  • OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White: Version A fits V1, V1 8K, V1 Max, V1 Ultra, V2, V2 Max, Q1, Q1 Pro, Q1 Max, Q1 Ultra, Q1 HE, 81 Pro, Q2, Q2 Pro, Q2 Max, K2, K2 Pro, K2 Max, K2 HE, K2 Ultra, Lemokey L1, P1, P1 Pro, and P1 HE. If you own one of these models, Version A is the catalog-confirmed match.
  • OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White: Version B fits V3, V3 8K, V3 Max, V3 Ultra, V4, V4 Max, V6, V6 Max, V6 Ultra, Q3, Q3 Pro, Q3 Max, Q3 Ultra, Q3 HE, Q4, Q4 Pro, Q4 HE, Q0, Q6, Q6 Pro, Q6 Max, Q6 Ultra, Q6 HE, Lemokey L3, L4, K8, K8 Version 2, K8 Pro, K8 Max, K8 Ultra, K10, K10 Version 2, K10 Pro, K10 Max, K10 Ultra, K12, K12 Pro, C1, C1 Pro, C2, and C2 Pro. Version B covers a different cluster of boards, including several K8, K10, and C-series models.
  • OEM Dye-Sub PBT Keycap Set - Bluish Black White: Version C (Full Set) fits Q HE series, Q series (excluding Alice Layout keyboard, Split Layout keyboard, Q9 Plus), V and V 8K and V Max series (excluding Alice Layout keyboard), 81 Pro, Lemokey L1, L3, L4, P1, P1 Pro, P1 HE, K2, K2 Pro, K2 Max, K2 HE, K2 Ultra, K4, K4 Pro, K4 Max, K4 HE, K4 Ultra, K6, K6 Pro, K6 HE, K8, K8 Version 2, K8 Pro, K8 Max, K8 HE, K8 Ultra, K10, K10 Version 2, K10 Pro, K10 Max, K10 HE, K10 Ultra, K12, K12 Pro, K14, K14 Pro, C1, C1 Pro, C2, and C2 Pro. Version C is the broadest option in the OEM set, but it still excludes Alice and Split layouts and the Q9 Plus.

MDA New York vs OEM Bluish Black White at a glance

Use this table to compare the confirmed catalog facts. Anything not listed here is not confirmed by the supplied records.

  • Profile: MDA (New York) vs OEM (Bluish Black White). The catalog names the profiles but does not describe their height or shape.
  • Material and legend method: Both are dye-sub PBT. The catalog does not provide additional material or durability details.
  • Set size and versioning: New York is a single Full Set (140 keys). Bluish Black White comes in Version A, Version B, and Version C (Full Set), and you must choose the right version for your keyboard.
  • Keyboard compatibility: New York lists specific ANSI-layout models and exclusions. Bluish Black White lists models per version. Check your exact model against the relevant list before ordering.
  • Price (catalog): New York: USD 29.59 (comparison price USD 39.99). Bluish Black White: USD 30.49 (comparison price USD 49.99). Prices are as listed in the catalog and may change.
  • Discount note: The New York set record states no discount codes can be used. The Bluish Black White record does not state a discount policy.

Typing feel: what the profiles tell you and what they do not

MDA and OEM are different keycap profiles, so the typing feel will differ, but the supplied catalog does not describe the height, angle, or surface shape of either profile. That means you cannot use these records to predict exactly how each set will feel under your fingers.

What the records do confirm is that both sets use dye-sub PBT. If you already know you prefer PBT keycaps, both are in that family. For the specific feel difference between MDA and OEM, you will need to rely on the profile names and any hands-on experience you have, not on claims from this catalog.

A practical way to choose between the two sets

  1. 1. Confirm your keyboard model: Write down the exact model name. For the New York set, check it against the ANSI-layout list and exclusions. For the Bluish Black White set, check which version lists your model.
  2. 2. Decide whether you need a full set or a version-specific set: The New York set is one 140-key full set. The Bluish Black White set requires choosing Version A, B, or C. If your board appears in multiple versions, pick the one that matches your layout needs.
  3. 3. Compare the listed prices without assuming discounts: Use the catalog prices as a starting point. The New York record explicitly says no discount codes can be used; the Bluish Black White record does not mention discounts.
  4. 4. Accept the profile uncertainty: If you have never typed on MDA or OEM, the catalog cannot tell you which feels better. Consider the profile name as a starting preference, not a guarantee.

Where the catalog stops short

The supplied records do not include keycap height measurements, legend contrast details, or installation instructions for either set. They also do not confirm whether either set includes a keycap puller or other tools.

If you need those details, treat them as unconfirmed by this catalog rather than assuming they are missing from the product. The safest approach is to base your decision on the compatibility lists, set sizes, and prices that are explicitly stated.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile